The features of human decision making for complex interdisciplinary problems solution
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.20535/SRIT.2308-8893.2017.3.08Keywords:
decision making, limited rationality, environmental rationality, experimental economics, neuroeconomicsAbstract
The peculiarities of decision making by a person, considered by D. Kaneman and V. Smith, were analyzed. The limitation of the assumption of constructivist rationality underlying the classical economic theory, when postulating the rationality of the behavior of all its participants, each of which always manages to maximize its utility function, is considered. The connection between the internal way of thinking (how the mind or brain works) and the behavior in the conditions of individual decision-making, social interaction, market institutions are discussed. Some further directions of research and settings are proposed along with the opportunities for new formulations of interdisciplinary tasks, including system analysis and modeling. The results of research on the experimental economy from the observation of its state in the studies of existing market institutions are presented. Constructive and environmental rationality, neuroeconomics and possibilities of their mutual influence are considered.References
Horbachuk V.M. Suspil'ni ta universytets'ki zminy vid Tret'oyi do Chetvertoyi promyslovoyi revoljutsiyi / V.M. Horbachuk // Classic university in the context of challenges of the epoch (September 22–23, 2016, Kyiv). — Kyiv: T.Shevchenko Kyiv National University, 2016. — S. 215–216.
Horbachuk V.M. Hlobal'ni investytsiyi u majbutnij ljuds'kyj kapital / V.M. Horbachuk // Hlobal'ni ta natsional'ni problemy ekonomiky. — 2016. — Vyp. 13. — S. 633–638.
Horbachuk V.M. Na porozi Chetvertoyi promyslovoyi revoljutsiyi / V.M. Horbachuk // Prychornomors'ki ekonomichni studiyi. — 2016. — Vyp. 8. — S. 216–220.
Kahneman D. Intuitive prediction: biases and corrective prodecures. Technical report RTR-1042-77-6 / D. Kahneman, A. Tversky. — Eugene, OR: Decision Research; A Branch of Perceptronics. Arlington, VA: Office of Naval Research; DARPA, 1977. — 44 p.
Kaneman D. Prinjatie reshenij v neopredelennosti: pravila i predubezhdenija / D. Kaneman, P. Slovik, A. Tverski. — H.: In-t prikladnoj psihologii "Gumanitarnyj Tsentr", 2005. — 632 s.
Kaneman D. Dumaj medlenno … Reshaj bystro / D. Kaneman. — M.: AST, 2016. — 656 s.
Smit V. Konstruktivistskaja i ekologicheskaja ratsional'nost' v ekonomicheskoj teorii / V. Smit // Ekovest. — 2006. — Vyp. 5. — № 4. — S. 536–617.
Smith V.L. Constructivist and ecological rationality in economics / V.L. Smith // Les Prix Nobel 2002. T.Frängsmyr (ed.). — Stockholm: Nobel Foundation, 2003. — P. 502–561.
Tirol' Zh. Rynki i rynochnaja vlast': teorija organizatsii promyshlennosti / Zh. Tirol'. — SPb: Ekon. shk., 1996. — 745 s.
Tirol' Zh. Rynki i rynochnaja vlast': teorija organizatsii promyshlennosti / Zh. Tirol'. — SPb: Ekon. shk., 2000. — T. 1. — 384 s.; T. 2. — 592 s.
Horbachuk V.M. Metody industrial'noyi orhanizatsiyi. Kejsy ta vpravy. Ekonomika ta orhanizatsija vyrobnytstva. Ekonomichna kibernetyka. Ekonomika pidpryyemstva / V.M. Horbachuk. — K.: A.S.K., 2010. — 224 s.
Horbachuk V.M. Nejrofiziolohija pryjnjattja rishen' ljudynoju / V.M. Horbachuk, O.S. Makarenko // VII Konhres Ukrayins'koho tovarystva nejronauk. — K.: In-t fiziolohiyi im. O.O.Bohomol'tsja NAN Ukrayiny, 2017. — S. 82.
Pindajk R.S. Mikroekonomika / R.S. Pindajk, D.L. Rubinfel'd. — K.: Osnovy, 1996. — 646 s.
Hayek F. The fatal conceit / F. Hayek. — Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1988. — 194 p.
Tversky A. Rational choice and the framing of decisions / A. Tversky, D. Kahneman / Rational choice. R.M.Hogarth, M.W.Reder (eds.). — Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1987. — P. 167–192.
Gigerenzer G. Simple heuristics that make us smart / G. Gigerenzer, P.M. Todd. —NY: Oxford; ABC Research Group, 1999. — 432 p.
Smith V.L. Papers in experimental economics / V.L. Smith. — Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1991. — 828 p.
Smith V.L. Bargaining and market behavior / V.L. Smith. — Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2000. — 474 p.
Plott C. Equilibrium, equilibration, information and multiple markets: from basic science to institutional design / C. Plott // Nobel Symposium (December 4–6, 2001). Behavioral and experimental economics. — Grand Hotel Saltsjöbaden, 2001. — 52 p.
Berg J. Risk preference instability across institutions: a dilemma / J. Berg, J. Dickhaut, K. McCabe. — Minneapolis, MN: Carlson School of Management, University of Minnesota. — Working paper. — 1994. — P. 4209–4214.
Smith V.L. Monetary rewards and decision cost in strategic interactions / V.L. Smith, F. Szidarovszky // Models of a man: essays in memory of Herbert A. Simon. M.Augier, J.March (eds.). — Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2002. — P. 169–182.
Gazzaniga M.S. The mind’s past / M.S. Gazzaniga. — Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1998. — 263 p.
Hayek F.A. Studies in philosophy politics and economics / F.A. Hayek. — Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press. 1967. — 356 p.
Pinker S. The language instinct / S. Pinker. — New York, NY: William Morrow, 1994. — 494 p.
Kagan J. The emergence of morality in young children / J. Kagan, S. Lamb. — Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1987. — 374 p.
Kagan J. Galen’s prophecy / J. Kagan. — New York, NY: Basic Books, 1994. — 376 p.
Fiske A.P. The structures of social life: the four elementary forms of human relations / A.P. Fiske. — New York, NY: Free Press, 1991. — 500 p.
Knowlton B. A neostriatal habit learning system in humans / B. Knowlton, J. Mangels, L. Squire // Science. — 1996. — 273. — P. 1399–1402.
Pinker S. The blank slate / S. Pinker. — New York, NY: Viking, 2002. — 528 p.
Segal N. Entwined lives / N. Segal. — New York, NY: Plume, 1999. — 396 p.
Goldberger A. Heritability / A. Goldberger // Economica. — 1979. — 46. — P. 327–347.
Horbachuk V.M. Vtrata efektyvnosti v rivnovahakh Nesha / V.M. Horbachuk, N.I. Harkusha // Matematychne modeljuvannja v ekonomitsi. — 2013. — 3. — S. 79–89.
Hume D. A treatise of human nature / D. Hume. — London, UK: Penguin Books, 1985. — 688 p.
H’jum D. Traktat pro ljuds'ku pryrodu / D. H’jum. — K.: Vsesvit, 2003. — 552 s.
Simon H. The sciences of the artificial. 3-rd edition / H. Simon. — Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1996.
Sajmon G. Nauki ob iskusstvennom / G. Sajmon. — M.: Mir, 1972. — 142 s.
Serhiyenko I.V. Induktyvna matematyka / I.V. Serhiyenko, A.M. Hupal // Visn. NAN Ukrayiny. — 2002. — № 5. — S. 19–25.
Smith A. The theory of moral sentiments / A. Smith. — Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Classics, 1982. — 412 p.
Zavertanyy V. Genotype dynamic for agent neuroevolution in artificial life model / V. Zavertanyy, A. Makarenko // Systemni doslidzhennja ta informatsijni tekhnolohiyi. — 2017. — № 1. — S. 75–87.
Zywicki T.J. Posner, Hayek, and the economic analysis of law / T.J. Zywicki, A.B. Sanders // Iowa law review. — 2008. — 93. — P. 559–603.
North D.C. Structure and change in economic history / D.C. North. — New York, NY: Norton, 1981. — 240 p.
Nort D. Instytutsiyi, instytutsijna zmina ta funktsionuvannja ekonomiky / D. Nort. — K.: Osnovy, 2000. — 198 s.
Ostrom E. Governing the commons / E. Ostrom. — Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1990. — 298 p.
Ostrom E. Keruvannja spil'nym / E. Ostrom. — K.: Nash chas, 2012. — 400 s.
McCabe K. A functional imaging study of cooperation in two-person reciprocal exchange / K. McCabe, D. Houser, L. Ryan, V.L. Smith, T. Trouard // Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. — 2001. — 98. — P. 11832–11835.
Friedman D. On the efficiency of double auction markets / D. Friedman // American economic review. — 1984. — 74. — P.60–72.
Wilson R.B. On equilibria of bid-ask markets / R.B. Wilson // Arrow and the ascent of modern economic theory. G.Feiwel (ed.) — New York, NY: NYU Press, 1987. — P. 375–414.
Wilson R.B. Design of efficient trading procedure / R.B. Wilson // The double auction market: institutions, theories, and evidence. J.Friedman, J.Rust (eds.). — Reading, MA: Santa Fe Institute Studies in the Sciences and Complexity; Addison-Wesley, 1993. — P. 125–152.
Bronfman C. An experimental examination of the Walrasian tatonnement mechanism / C. Bronfman, K. McCabe, D. Porter, S. Rassenti, V.L. Smith // RAND journal of economics. — 1996. — 27. — P. 681–699.
Smith V.L. An experimental study of competitive market behavior / V.L. Smith // Journal of political economy. — 1962. — 70. — P. 111–137.
Smith V.L. Microeconomic systems as an experimental science / V.L. Smith // American economic review. — 1982. — 72 (5). — P. 923–955.
Davis D. Experimental economics / D. Davis, C. Holt. — Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1993. — 584 p.
Kagel J. Handbook of experimental economics / J. Kagel, A. Roth. — Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1995. — 744 p.
Ketcham J. A comparison of posted-offer and double-auction pricing institutions / J. Ketcham, V.L. Smith, A. Williams // Review of economic studies. — 1984. — 51. — P. 595–614.
Deck C. Tracking customer search to price discriminate / C. Deck, B. Wilson // Economic inquiry. — 2006. — 44 (2). — P. 280–295.
Smith V.L. Experimental economics: induced value theory / V.L. Smith // American economic review proceedings. — 1976. — 66. — P. 274–279.
Smith V.L. Relevance of laboratory experiments to testing resource allocation theory / V.L. Smith // Evaluation of econometric models. J.Kmenta, J.B. Ramsey (eds.) — NY: Academic Press, 1980. — P. 345–377.
Gode D.K. Allocative efficiency of markets with zero-intelligence traders: market as a partial substitute for individual rationality / D.K. Gode, S. Sunder // Journal of political economy. — 1993. — 101 (1). — P. 119–137.
Sunder S. Market as artifact: aggregate efficiency from zero intelligence traders / S. Sunder // Models of a man: essays in memory of Herbert A. Simon. — Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2002. — P. 501–520.
Miller R. Don’t let your robots grow up to be traders: artificial intelligence, human intelligence, and asset-market bubbles / R. Miller // Journal of economic behavior and organization. — 2008. — 68 (1). — P. 153–166.
Gorbachuk V.M. Cournot–Nash equilibria and Bertrand–Nash equilibria for a heterogenous duopoly of differentiated products / V.M. Gorbachuk // Cybernetics and systems analysis. — 2010. — Vol. 46. — № 1. — P. 25–33.
Smith V.L. Experimental methods in the political economy of exchange / V.L. Smith // Science. — 1986. — 234. — P. 167–173.
Williams A. Simultaneous trading in two competitive markets: an experimental examination / A. Williams, V.L. Smith, J.O. Ledyard. — Bloomington, IN: Department of Economics; Indiana University, 1986. — P. 167–173.
Williams A. Concurrent trading in two experimental markets with demand interdependence / A. Williams, V.L. Smith, J.O. Ledyard, S. Gjerstad // Journal of economic theory. — 2000. — 16. — P. 511–528.
Plott C. Research on pricing in a gas transportation network. Technical report 88-2 / C. Plott. — Washington, DC: Office of Economic policy; Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, 1988. — 27 p.
Smith V.L. Bubbles, crashes and endogenous expectations in experimental spot asset markets / V.L. Smith, G. Suchanek, A. Williams // Econometrica. — 1988. — 56. — P. 49–51.
Porter D. Stock market bubbles in the laboratory / D. Porter, V.L. Smith // Applied mathematical finance. — 1994. — 1. — P. 111–127.
Dufwenberg M. Bubbles and experience: an experiment / M. Dufwenberg, T. Lindqvist, E. Moore // American economic review. — 2005. — 95 (5). — P. 1731–1737.
Damasio A.R. Descartes error: emotion, reason, and the human brain / A.R. Damasio. — NY: Putnam, 1994.
Bechara A. Deciding advantageously before knowing the advantageous strategy / A. Bechara, H. Damasio, D. Tranel, A.R. Damascio // Science. — 1997. — 275. — P. 1293–1295.
Goel V. A study of the performance of patients with frontal lobe lesions in a financial planning task / V. Goel, J. Grafman, J. Tajik, S. Gana, D. Danto // Brain. — 1997. — 120. — P. 1805–1822.
Horbachuk V.M. Finansovi metody / V.M. Horbachuk. — K.: Al'terpres, 2002. — 175 s.
Roelofs O. The subjective duration of time-intervals: the influence of order in the estimation of duration of two successive intervals / O. Roelofs, W.P.C. Zeeman // Acta psychologica. — 1949. — 6. — P. 126–177.
Tremblay L. Relative reward preference in primate orbitofrontal cortex / L. Tremblay, W. Schultz // Nature. — 1999. — 398. — P. 704–708.
Kahneman D. Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk / D. Kahneman, A. Tversky // Econometrica. — 1979. — 47. — P. 263–291.
Mellers B.A. Decision affect theory: how we feel about risky options / B.A. Mellers, A. Schwartz, K. Ho, J. Ritov // Phychological science. — 1997. — 8. — P. 423–429.
Breiter HC. Functional imaging of neural responses to expectancy and experience of monetary gains and losses / HC. Breiter, I. Aharon, D. Kahneman, A. Dale, P. Shizgal // Neuron. — 2001. — 30. — P. 619–639.
Thut G. Activation of the human brain by monetary reward / G. Thut, W. Schultz, U. Roelcke et al. // NeuroReport. — 1997. — 8. — P. 1225–1228.
Schultz W. Multiple reward signals in the brain / W. Schultz // Nature reviews: neuroscience. — 2000. — 1. — P. 199–207.
Schultz W. Getting formal with dopamine and reward / W. Schultz // Neuron. — 2002. — 36. — P. 241–263.
Fletcher P. Other minds in the brain: a functional imaging study of "theory of mind" story comprehension / P. Fletcher, F. Happe, U. Frith et al. // Cognition. — 1995. — 57. — P. 109–128.
Zgurovskij M.Z. Tsifrovaja nauka v programme "Gorizont 2020" / M.Z. Zgurovskij, A.I. Petrenko // Systemni doslidzhennja ta informatsijni tekhnolohiyi. — 2015. — № 1. — S. 7–20.
Makarenko A. Multiscale and applied system analysis of a brain activity. I. General description / A. Makarenko // Algebras, groups, and geometries. — Palm Harbor, FL: Hadronic Press. — 2015. — Vol. 32. — N 4. — P. 449–460.
Kryshtal' O. Nauka ta mystetstvo: dvi nohy dlja postupu. Inavguratsijna lektsija pochesnoho profesora Natsional'noho universytetu "Kyyevo-Mohyljans'ka akademija". — K.: NaUKMA, 2017. — 24 s.
