Complex deterministic evaluation of the complex hierarchical-network systems: Part I. methods description
Abstract
The main approaches and methods for evaluation of complex systems are analyzed and their advantages and disadvantages are determined. Systems with hierarchical-network structures are described and methods are proposed for their complex deterministic evaluation. Methods of multicriteria and multiparameter local, forecasting, aggregative, and interactive analyses of the state, function quality and interaction of system’s objects on the all hierarchical levels are described. The scheme of interaction is described and it is justified that the proposed methods only in conjunction allow to form objective and grounded conclusions about the quality of a complex system. The proposed methods are illustrated using the analysis of the functioning efficiency of objects of the Ukrainian railway transport system as an example.References
Antonov V.A. Sistemnyj analiz. — M.: Vysshaja shkola, 2004. — 456 s.
Boccatti S., Latora V., Moreno Y., Chavez M., Hwang D.-U. Complex networks: structure and dynamics // Physics Reports. — 2006. — 424. — P. 175–308.
Siljak D.D. Decentralized control of complex systems. — Courier Dover Publications, 2012. — 612 p.
Buslenko N.P. Modelirovanie slozhnyh sistem. — M.: Nauka, 1978. — 542 s.
Polishchuk D.O., Polishchuk O.D., Jadzhak M.S. Porivnjannja metodiv otsinjuvannja skladnykh system // Vidbir i obrobka informatsiyi. — 2010. — Vyp. 32 (108). — S. 110–118.
Alcorta G.E., Frank P.M. Deterministic nonlinear observer-based approaches to fault diagnosis: A survey // Control Engineering Practice. — 1997. — 5 (5). — P. 663–670.
Bloom M., Fischer J., Orme J. Evaluating practice. — Allyn and Bacon, 2006. — 488 p.
Ramsey F., Schafer D. The statistical sleuth: A course in methods of data analysis. — Duxbury Press, 2001. — 532 p.
Claxton K. The irrelevance of inference: a decision-making approach to the stochastic evaluation of health care technologies // Journal of Health Economics. — 1999. — 18 (3). — P. 341–364.
Lee J., Jay Kuo C.-C. Tree model simplification with hybrid polygon/billboard approach and human-centered quality evaluation // Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Multimedia and Expo. — Singapore. — July 19–23, 2010. — P. 932–937.
Bar-Yam Y. About engineering complex systems: Multiscale analysis and evolutionary engineering // Engineering Self-Organising Systems: Methodologies and Applications. — Springer, 2005. — P. 16–31.
Roy D., Dasgupta T. Evaluation of reliability of complex systems by means of a discretizing approach // International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management. — 2002 . — 19. — № 6. — P. 792–801.
Armitage P. Statistical methods in medical research. — Blackwell Science, 2002. — 712 p.
Patton M.Q. How to use qualitative methods in evaluation. — Sage Publications, 1987. — 490 p.
Kornikov V.V., Seregin I.A., Hovanov N.V. Kompleksnaja otsenka vozdejstvija geopatogennyh zon na biologicheskie sistemy // Voprosy mehaniki i protsessov upravlenija. — 2000. — Vyp. 18. — S. 113–117.
Su C.-L. Stochastic evaluation of voltages in distribution networks with distributed generation using detailed distribution operation models // IEEE Transactions on Power Systems. — 2010. — 25, № 2. — P. 786–795.
Diligenskij N.V., Dymova L.G., Sevast'janov P.V. Nechetkoe modelirovanie i mnogokriterial'naja optimizatsija proizvodstvennyh sistem v uslovijah neopredelennosti: tehnologija, ekonomika, ekologija. — M.: Mashinostroenie, 2004. — 458 s.
Hovanov H.B. Otsenka slozhnyh ekonomicheskih ob'ektov i protsessov v uslovijah neopredelennosti // Vestnik SPbGU. Ser. 5. — 2005. — Vyp. 1. — S. 139–143.
Krut'ko V.N., Slavin M.B., Smirnova T.M. Matematicheskie osnovanija gerontologii: Obschaja teorija zdorov'ja; teorija nadezhnosti v zhivyh i nezhivyh sistemah; sovremennye metody analiza biologicheskogo vozrasta, starenija i prodolzhitel'nosti zhizni. — M.: URSS, 2002. — 384 s.
Dombi J. Basic concepts for a theory of evaluation: the aggregative operator // European Journal of Operational Research. — 1982. — 10, № 3. — P. 282–293.
Bogdanchuk V.Z., Egorov B.M., Katulev A.N. Agregirovanie vektornyh kriteriev. — L.: LIIAN, 1990. — 214 s.
Lung-Wen T. Distributed real time systems: monitoring, visualization, debugging and analysis. — Lavoisier, 1996. — 336 p.
Owen C.L. Evaluation of complex systems // Designe Studies. — 2007. — 28. — № 1. — P. 73–101.
Hwang C.L., Tillman F.A., Lee J. System-reliability evaluation techniques for complex / large systems. A review // IEEE Transactions, Reliability. — 1981. — R-30, № 30. — P. 416–423.
Kalashnikov V.V. Slozhnye sistemy i metody ih analiza. — M.: Znanie, 1980. — 211 s.
Krisilov V.A. Otsenka slozhnyh ob'ektov — osnovnoj mehanizm kolichestvennogo obosnovanija pri prinjatii reshenij // Tr. Odesskogo politehn. un-ta. — 2002. — Vyp. 2 (18). — S. 45–49.
Evlanov L.G. Teorija i praktika prinjatija reshenij. — M.: Ekonomika, 1984. — 176 s.
Marakas G.M. Decision support systems in the 21st Century. — Pearson Education, 2003. — 638 p.
Dubov Ju.A., Travkin S.I., Jakimets V.N. Mnogokriterial'nye modeli formirovanija i vybora variantov sistem. — M.: Nauka, 1986. — 354 s.
Sadovskij V.N. Osnovanija obschej teorii sistem. Logiko-metodologicheskij analiz. — M: Mysl', 1974. — 346 s.
Sarkisjan S.A. Bol'shie tehnicheskie sistemy. Analiz i prognoz razvitija. — M.: Nauka, 1977. — 438 s.
Kolesov Ju.B. Ob'ektno-orientirovannoe modelirovanie slozhnyh dinamicheskih sistem. — SPb.: Izd-vo SPbGPU, 2004. — 240 s.
Barabási A.-L. The architecture of complexity // IEEE Control Systems Magazine. — 2007. — 27, № 4. — P. 33–42.
Ofitsijnyj sajt Ukrzaliznytsi. — http://www.uz.gov.ua.
Nechiporenko V.I. Strukturnyj analiz sistem. — M.: Sovetskoe radio, 1977. — 286 s.
Mesarovich M., Maho D., Takahara I. Teorija ierarhicheskih mnogourovnevyh sistem. — M.: Nauka, 1975. — 314 s.
Voronin A.N. Metod mnogokriterial'noj otsenki i optimizatsii ierarhicheskih sistem // Kibernetika i sistemnyj analiz. — 2007. — № 3. — S. 84–92.
Poljanskij S.V., Semenov I.B., Chizhov S.A. Kompleksnoe otsenivanie v zadachah upravlenija sistemami sotsial'no-ekonomicheskogo tipa. — M.: IPU RAN, 1996. — 48 s.
Krejnis Z.L., Korshunova N.P. Tehnicheskoe obsluzhivanie i remont zheleznodorozhnogo puti. — M.: UMK MPSR, 2001. — 768 s.
Polishchuk D.O. Model' lokal'noho otsinjuvannja stanu elementiv kolijnoho hospodarstva Ukrzaliznytsi // Visnyk Dnipropetrovs'koho natsional'noho universytetu zaliznychnoho transportu imeni ak. V. Lazarjana. — 2012. — Vyp. 41. — S. 158–166.
Lichtberger B.W. Kostensenkung durch qualitatsvorrat in der fahrweginstandhaltung // Der Eisenbahningenieur. — 1999. — 50, № 1. — P. 39–42.
Polishchuk D., Polishchuk O. About evaluation of complex dynamical systems // Journal of Complex Systems. — 2013, Article ID 204304, 6 p. — http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1155/2013/ 204304.
Polischuk A.D. Optimizatsija otsenki kachestva funktsionirovanija slozhnyh dinamicheskih sistem // Problemy upravlenija i informatiki. — 2004. — № 4. — S. 39–44.
Kacira M., Ling P.P. Design and development of an automated and non-contact sensing system for continuous monitoring of plant health and growth // Transactions of ASAE. — 2001. — 44(4). — P. 989–996.
Polishchuk D.O., Polishchuk O.D. Monitorynh potoku transportnykh merezh iz chastkovo vporjadkovanym rukhom // Zb. nauk. prats' KhKhIII nauk.-tekhn. konf. molodykh naukovtsiv Fizyko-mekhanichnoho instytutu im. H.V. Karpenka NANU. — 23–25 zhovtnja, 2013. — L'viv, Ukrayina. — S. 326–329.
Vnukov A.B. Sovremennye sistemy navigatsii i slezhenija za nazemnymi transportnymi sredstvami na baze sputnikovyh tehnologij // Gornaja promyshlennost'. — 2006. — № 6. — S. 97–101.
Norros L., Saviola P. Usability evaluation of complex systems. A literature review. — Helsinki: STUK, 2004. — 44 p.
